2026 New Jersey Softball All State 50
For the first time, NJ Athletics is proud to unveil our All-State 50 for New Jersey softball. This inaugural list recognizes 50 of the top players from across the state who made a lasting impact during the 2026 season. From dominant pitchers and power hitters to defensive standouts and all-around playmakers, each athlete earned their place through consistent production, leadership, and performances against New Jersey's top competition.
Presented in no particular order, the NJ Athletics All-State 50 celebrates the depth of talent across the Garden State and recognizes the players who helped define the 2026 softball season.
2026 New Jersey Softball All State 50
- P: Madison McDougall, St. John Vianney
- P: Brooke Donofrio, Ramsey
- P: McKenna Savage, Red Bank Catholic
- P: Abby Busser, Waldwick
- P: Riley Smith, Middletown South
- P: Ava Kelshaw, Mount St. Dominic
- P: Riley Bobrowski, Watchung Hills
- P: Ellie Miller, Steinert
- P: Gianna Gomez, Barnegat
- P: Emma Anderson, Hillsborough
- P: Emily Shiner, Northern Burlington
- P: Audrey Amoruso, Indian Hills
- P: Gylian Hixenbaugh, Donovan Catholic
- P/1B: Claire Shupe, Columbia
- P/1B: Charlotte Yarnall, Summit
- P/INF: Brooke Douglass, Ocean City
- P/INF: Cailyn Centeno, Delsea
- P/INF: Emily Gaudio, Marlboro
- C: Chloe Jacobson, Summit
- C: Olivia Lombardi, St. John Vianney
- C: Cassidy Smith, Randolph
- C: Jaelynn Nunez, Donovan Catholic
- C: Jayden Kane, Red Bank Catholic
- C: Leah Catto, Ocean City
- 1B: Jillian Cianfrocca, Mount St. Dominic
- 1B: Hailey Seubert, Watchung Hills
- INF: Gabby Gonzalez, St. John Vianney
- INF: Kaelyn Brown, DePaul
- INF: Alexandra Hsu, North Hunterdon
- INF: Brynn Utter, St. John Vianney
- INF: Julia Fox, Morris Knolls
- INF: Isabella Cino, Donovan Catholic
- INF: Mia Pope, Steinert
- INF: Gemma DeJoseph, Delran
- INF: Taylor Heinemann, Morris Knolls
- INF: Grace McManus, Old Tappan
- INF: Isabella Wuelfing, Marlboro
- INF: Leah English, Immaculate Heart
- INF: Kaci Velardi, Egg Harbor
- INF: Bianca Walsh, Steinert
- OF: Mia Favato, St. John Vianney
- OF: Bella Baldino, Ramsey
- OF: Alaina Dorsey, St. Joseph Hammonton
- OF: Isabella Maria, Donovan Catholic
- OF: Lily Allmendinger, Passaic Valley
- OF: Olivia Videla, Watchung Hills
- OF: Emma Speyerer, Audubon
- OF: Ava Sweet, Rancocas Valley
- OF: Jules Jackson, Paul VI
- OF: Bailey Schoenfeldt, Gloucester