2025 New Jersey Baseball All State Teams

by NJ Athletics June 28, 2025

The 2025 New Jersey high school baseball season has wrapped up in style—and it's time to recognize the players who shined brightest. Our All-State honors spotlight those who excelled at every position across the state, from power pitchers to clutch hitters and defensive standouts. These accolades include First, Second, and Third Team All-State selections, along with Honorable Mentions for players who made a significant impact.

First Team

P: Marcelo Harsch - Seton Hall Prep
P: Henry Radbill, Cherokee
P: Corey Pascarella, Colonia
C: Micky Gilligan, Passaic Tech
INF: Zach Geertsma, Gov. Livingston
INF: Jason Amalbert, DePaul
INF: Nick Becker, Don Bosco
INF: Sal Garcia, Delbarton
OF: Nick Dromboski, Northern Burlington
OF: Dylan Fitzsimmons, Morris Knolls
OF: Will Mahala, Seton Hall Prep
DH: Jacob Cagna, Egg Harbor Township
UTL: Luca Mannino, Northern Burlington

Second Team

P: Grant Como, Westfield
P: Frank Cairone, Delsea
P: Sean Budis, Brearley
C: Braeden Lipoff, Gloucester Catholic
INF: J.C. Pacheco, DePaul
INF: Cole Marchetti, Northern Burlington
INF: Brett Jackson, Cherokee
INF: Ricky Lopez, Ranney
OF: Chase Kroberger, Moorestown
OF: Michael Hannah, Don Bosco
OF: Matt Tafuri, Delbarton
DH: Julius Rosado, South River
UTL: Luke Pokrovsky, Schalick

Third Team

P: Jackson Smallets, Gloucester Catholic
P: Aidan Steiglitz, Ridge
P: Anthony Costello, Don Bosco
C: Nick Donofrio, Pascack Valley
INF: Chris Vaughn, Madison
INF: Luke Guire, Bordentown
INF: Jamie Zee, Bergen Catholic
INF: Evan Lagemann, Glen Rock
OF: Josh Hale, Jefferson
OF: Tyler Wiltsey, Audubon
OF: Jake Dolan, Ridge
DH: Jordan Burwell, Seton Hall Prep
UTL: Charlie Wingfield, Ramapo

Honorable Mentions

Pitchers
Li Perez, Rutgers Prep
Ethan Lee, Don Bosco
Brett Gable, Cherokee
Charlie Wingfield, Ramapo
Liam Costello, West Morris
Jake Lodgek, Mainland
JJ Drennan, Seton Hall Prep
Adam Goldberg, Livingston
Dan Nafziger, Toms River East
Keith Mann, Gov. Livingston
JT Deriso, Pascack Valley
Danny Ditullio, Christian Brothers

Catcher
Chase Bagley, Don Bosco
Henry Ayers, Seton Hall Prep
Mason Kelleher, Cherokee
Brody Barber, Ramapo
Andrew Paraisi, Ranney
Liam Velit, Northern Burlington
Mike Basile, Gov. Livingston
Joe McGlynn, Brick Memorial
Danny Tsimbinos, Christian Brothers

1st Base
Carter Cumisky, Spotswood
Lorenzo Camilleri, St. Peter’s Prep
Braedan Trajkovski, Westfield
Dan Golembiewski, Brick Memorial, Jr.
Matt Caruso, Passaic Tech

Infield
Alex Famolari, North Hunterdon
Eliezer Cepeda, Elizabeth
Vinny Milillo, Eastern
Joe Erace, St. Augustine
Dante Bell, Bishop Eustace
Ethan DuBois, Delsea
Aiden Ogando, DePaul
A.J. Terry, Randolph
Nicholas Gilpin, Don Bosco
Matt Ferrara, Toms River East

Outfield
Anthony Denora, Gov. Livingston
Derek Brand, DePaul
Ryan Pappas, Gov. Livingston
Kyle Shields, Kingsway
Liam Hayward, Ramapo
Joey Dwek, Gill St. Bernard’s

Utility
Finnian O'Loughlin, Delbarton
Matty Diskin, Gov. Livingston
Alex Odud, Cherokee
Wilme Mas Sarda, Union City
Jake Dolan, Ridge
Alex Weingartner, St. Augustine
Jack Mustaro, Gloucester Catholic
Chris Gioia, Rutherford
Evan Taylor, Ocean City
Jake Alfano, Westfield
Logan Chi, St. Peter's Prep